Granny's Pantry

Sesame Oil Substitute: The Best Swaps for Toasted and Plain

The short answer

The best substitute for toasted sesame oil is perilla oil or walnut oil, swapped 1:1. If you have neither, stir toasted sesame seeds into a neutral oil for the aroma, or thin a spoonful of tahini for dressings. Whichever you use, add it at the end of cooking — heat kills that toasty fragrance.

Mid-recipe and the sesame oil bottle is empty? Take a breath, love. The right swap depends on which sesame oil your recipe means — and you almost certainly have a stand-in on the shelf already.

Toasted sesame oil substitutes at a glance
SubstituteHow muchBest forThe catch
Perilla oil1:1The closest match — nutty and toasty, at home in stir-fries, noodles and Korean dishesSold in Korean groceries; like sesame oil, add it at the end, off the heat
Walnut oil1:1Dressings, noodles, drizzling over finished dishesNutty, but it is not sesame — the flavour is its own; too delicate to fry with
Toasted sesame seeds in a neutral oilSeeds to taste, stirred into a mild oilGetting real sesame aroma into fried rice and stir-friesToast the seeds in a dry pan first; the oil itself stays neutral
Tahini, thinnedThin a spoonful with water or a neutral oil until pourableDressings, sauces and marinadesIt is ground sesame, so the flavour is right, but it is a paste — it adds body, and it will not work as a finishing drizzle
Any neutral oil (vegetable, sunflower)1:1Replacing plain, untoasted sesame oil as an everyday cooking oilGives none of the roasted aroma — not a stand-in for the dark, toasted bottle

Toasted or Plain? Check Your Bottle First

This matters more than the swap itself. Most recipes — and most cooks searching mid-stir-fry — mean toasted sesame oil: the small dark bottle, deep amber-brown, smelling of roasted nuts. It is a finishing oil, there for aroma, not for frying. Plain (untoasted) sesame oil is a different thing entirely: pale, mild and neutral, an everyday cooking oil. Do not confuse the two. If your recipe says to drizzle it in at the end, it means toasted. If it says to fry the onions in it, it means plain — and any neutral oil will do the job.

The Best Substitutes for Toasted Sesame Oil

Swap by the job the oil was doing, not just oil for oil. Toasted sesame oil is there for its roasted, nutty aroma, so reach for something that brings aroma too. Perilla oil is the closest cousin — use it 1:1, and treat it just as gently. Walnut oil also works 1:1: it is nutty and lovely in dressings and over noodles, though the flavour is walnut, not sesame — do not expect a perfect match. No nut oils in the house? Add toasted sesame seeds to a neutral oil for the aroma — the trick below. And for dressings and sauces, thin a little tahini: it is ground sesame, so the flavour rings true.

The Toasted-Seeds Trick

This one earns its keep. Tip sesame seeds into a dry frying pan over medium heat and keep them moving until they turn golden and smell wonderful — a few minutes, no more, for they burn in a blink. Stir the warm seeds into a mild, neutral oil such as sunflower or vegetable oil, then use that where the recipe wanted toasted sesame oil. You can also simply scatter the toasted seeds straight over the finished dish. The oil stays neutral, mind — it is the seeds carrying the aroma — but in fried rice or a stir-fry, nobody will feel short-changed.

Add It at the End — Heat Kills the Aroma

Whatever you land on, remember the golden rule: toasted sesame oil is a finishing oil. Its fragrance is delicate, and hard heat drives it straight out of the pan. Stir it — or your perilla or walnut oil — through the dish right at the end, off the heat, and it will sing. Fry with it and you will wonder where the flavour went. Save the frying for a neutral oil and keep the good stuff for the last moment.

Substituting Plain (Untoasted) Sesame Oil

The easy one. Plain sesame oil is a neutral cooking oil, so any mild oil steps in 1:1 — vegetable, sunflower, canola (rapeseed) or a light olive oil. Your bake or fry-up will not know the difference. The one thing not to do is pour dark toasted sesame oil into the pan in its place: it will scorch, the aroma will vanish, and the flavour can turn bitter. Different bottles, different jobs.

Questions we get asked

Can I use olive oil instead of sesame oil?

If your recipe means plain (untoasted) sesame oil, yes — a light olive oil swaps in 1:1 as a neutral cooking oil. It is no substitute for toasted sesame oil, though: you get none of the roasted aroma. If it is all you have, stir some toasted sesame seeds into it.

Can I use vegetable oil instead of sesame oil?

For plain sesame oil, yes — 1:1, no fuss. For toasted sesame oil, vegetable oil on its own gives you nothing, because the whole point is the roasted aroma. Add toasted sesame seeds to the vegetable oil and you are most of the way there.

What can I use instead of sesame oil in fried rice?

Perilla oil or walnut oil, 1:1, stirred through at the very end, off the heat. Or skip the aromatic oil altogether and finish with a scatter of toasted sesame seeds — you keep the sesame flavour without the bottle.

Is tahini a good substitute for sesame oil?

In dressings, sauces and marinades, yes — tahini is ground sesame, so the flavour is right. Thin it with a little water or neutral oil until it pours. It is a paste, mind, so it adds body and will not work as a finishing drizzle over a hot dish.

Can I just leave sesame oil out?

You can. It is a finishing flavour, not a structural one — the dish will still cook up perfectly well, just without that toasty top note. A scatter of toasted sesame seeds over the plate brings most of it back.

Is toasted sesame oil the same as regular sesame oil?

No. Toasted sesame oil is dark, strongly aromatic and added at the end of cooking for flavour. Regular (plain, untoasted) sesame oil is pale and neutral — an everyday cooking oil. They do different jobs and do not swap for each other.

Kept in the family

One recipe a week, from the notebook.

No spam, no nonsense — just a proper recipe, tested and written down clearly.